One specialist stays with you from your first call through funding.
November, 2026
An annuity can provide income for years, but how much of that income is taxable? The answer depends on how you funded the annuity and how you receive the money.
A withdrawal from your insurer may be taxed differently from regular annuity income. Selling your contract or future payment rights can also have tax consequences.
Here’s what to know before you take money out or consider a sale.
Annuity earnings are generally tax-deferred, meaning you usually don’t pay federal income tax on the growth each year while it remains in the contract. Taxes may become due when you receive payments, withdraw money, surrender the contract, or sell eligible rights.
The taxable amount depends partly on the money used to purchase the annuity:
| How the annuity is funded | General federal tax treatment |
|---|---|
| Pre-tax money in a traditional retirement account | Distributions are generally taxable as ordinary income. After-tax contributions may change the taxable amount. |
| After-tax money outside a retirement account | Earnings are generally taxable. Your remaining after-tax investment can generally be returned tax-free. |
| Money in a Roth IRA | Qualified distributions are tax-free when the Roth IRA requirements are met. |
An annuity purchased outside a retirement account with after-tax money is often called a nonqualified annuity. The money you invested, adjusted for any tax-free amounts already received, is commonly called your cost basis or investment in the contract.
A Roth IRA has its own rules. Meeting the requirements for a tax-free qualified distribution generally involves a five-year period and an additional condition, such as reaching age 59½. The IRS explains these requirements in Publication 590-B.
A withdrawal means taking money from your annuity while keeping the contract open.
If you own a nonqualified annuity and withdraw money before annuitization, the IRS generally treats earnings as coming out first. The taxable earnings are followed by a tax-free return of your remaining investment.
Here’s a simple example:
Assuming you made no earlier withdrawals and the usual earnings-first rule applies, the full $10,000 withdrawal is generally taxable. The contract had $20,000 in earnings before the withdrawal.
Different rules can apply to older contracts. You can find more detail in IRS Publication 575.
A full surrender usually ends your contract. You receive the surrender amount from the insurance company instead of keeping the annuity.
The amount received above your unrecovered investment is generally taxable. Insurer surrender charges or other contract adjustments may also reduce the amount you receive.
Annuitization means converting your annuity into a stream of income payments under the contract.
If you purchased a nonqualified annuity with after-tax money, part of each annuitized payment may be treated as a tax-free return of your investment. The remaining portion is generally taxable as ordinary income.
The calculation often uses an exclusion ratio, which considers your investment in the contract and the expected payments. Once your investment has been recovered tax-free, later payments are generally fully taxable.
A monthly withdrawal does not automatically mean your contract has been annuitized. Ask your insurer which type of payment you’re receiving.
A taxable annuity distribution received before age 59½ may be subject to an additional 10% federal tax. That additional tax generally applies to the taxable portion, and exceptions are available in certain circumstances.
Reaching age 59½ can remove the early-distribution tax in many cases, but it does not make otherwise taxable earnings tax-free.
Your insurance company may also charge a surrender fee. An insurer’s fee and the IRS additional tax are separate costs.
Selling an annuity contract or eligible future payment rights can create a tax liability. The result depends on what you sell, how the annuity was funded, your remaining tax basis, and the terms of the transaction.
The IRS states that the portion of a gain based on accumulated interest when an annuity contract is sold before maturity is ordinary income. The same approach should not be assumed for every sale of selected payment rights; the transaction needs individual review. See IRS Publication 550.
A lump-sum sale may also bring taxable income into one year instead of spreading it across future years. Your tax professional can help you compare an offer with your estimated proceeds after taxes.
Structured settlement payments arising from eligible physical injury claims can have different tax treatment from a personally purchased annuity.
The original settlement, the payment rights, and the proposed transfer all matter. Court approval alone does not make an otherwise taxable annuity sale tax-free.
Retirement annuities can have restrictions on transfers. An individual retirement annuity must meet a federal nontransferability requirement, so you should not assume it can be sold to a buyer.
State income-tax rules vary. Some higher-income taxpayers may also owe Net Investment Income Tax on certain nonqualified annuity income.
A qualifying 1035 exchange may allow you to exchange one annuity for another while deferring recognition of gain. Receiving cash and then buying a new annuity does not automatically qualify as an exchange.
Keep your contract, purchase records, payment history, and any tax forms you receive. These documents can help a tax professional determine your remaining basis and explain the likely consequences of a transaction.
MySettlement can review your annuity documents and discuss whether your future payment rights may be eligible for purchase.
A quote can help you compare your options. Your tax professional can then help you understand the potential tax consequences before you decide.